After All These Years, Amazon Is Finally Beatable


AI shopping gives eCommerce retailers a rare chance to be recommended ahead of Amazon.

When I ask AI to help me shop, I rarely get sent to Amazon. I usually start the conversation with a rough idea of what I need. A few questions later, I’ve narrowed down what I’m looking for, compared brands, and gotten a link to buy from a retailer. By the time I visit the store, I’m more confident about my purchase than ever.

For decades, Amazon gave shoppers good reasons to start there. Its marketplace offered broad selection, and its fulfillment network and Prime made fast, free shipping routine for members. Retailers could sell through Amazon to reach those shoppers, but marketplace fees could cut into their margins.

 

As retailers plan for 2027, Amazon is no longer unbeatable. When shoppers turn to AI for help, other retailers have a chance to earn the recommendation.

What the referral data actually shows

In August 2025, ChatGPT accounted for less than 3% of Amazon’s referral traffic, according to Similarweb. That same month, it accounted for about 20% of Walmart’s referral traffic, more than 20% of Etsy’s, and nearly 15% of Target’s.

The opening is in the shopping recommendation

In a September 2026 U.S. test, Suff Digital found that none of the 7,048 ChatGPT shopping cards listed Amazon as the merchant. Walmart appeared on 15.8%, Best Buy on 11.9%, and Target on 10.3%.

Amazon still appears in written recommendations. In October 2026, Sauron found that ChatGPT named Amazon in 15.3% of 144 answers to neutral shopping questions. Amazon appeared on the first page of Google’s organic results in 50.9% of 281 searches across the same 18 categories. This snapshot suggests an opening for competitors in AI recommendations, even in categories where Amazon appeared frequently on Google’s first page.

Why Amazon’s discovery advantage could weaken

Amazon’s on-site search engines have not evolved much, still providing long lists of results and requiring the shopper to wade through their options. AI assistants can help shoppers narrow down their options before they visit a retailer’s site. Other eCommerce sites can compete for those recommendations by making current product information easy for assistants to find. In November 2025, Modern Retail reported that Amazon had restricted several OpenAI crawlers, including tools for live web retrieval and search. If Amazon continues to limit outside assistants’ access, retailers that share accurate and complete catalogs have an opening.

Give the shopper a reason to buy from you

The opportunity starts with discovery, and the sale still has to be won. In an August 2026 survey of 2,191 U.S. consumers, PYMNTS Intelligence found that 59.4% of respondents who had used AI for product discovery or shopping in the past year said they now use it to research products they previously searched for on Amazon.

Start with one product category where your team’s expertise matters. Compare your product detail pages with the pages AI assistants already surface for specific buying questions. Add the verified specs, compatibility, use cases, and trade-offs that help shoppers choose. Keep pricing and availability current across your product pages and feeds, and make delivery and returns clear. OpenAI says ChatGPT uses availability, price, and quality, among other factors, to rank merchants that offer the same product. Then update your content at least once a quarter to keep it fresh–an AI trust signal.

You can beat Amazon on the next purchase if your site provides better answers than your competitors and a good reason to buy.

About DynEcom

DynEcom specializes in automating the competitive content process for eCommerce product detail pages. DynEcom helps sites optimize for traditional SEO search and AI chatbots, and by providing the decision content customers need, it also delivers higher conversion rates.

Sources

Amazon, 2025 Form 10-K

Amazon, Selling Plans and Referral Fees

Digiday / Modern Retail, Similarweb Referral Data for August 2025

Suff Digital, ChatGPT Product Card Study, September 2026

GEOly, Who Owns the AI Shopping Shelf?

Sauron, Where Does ChatGPT Tell You to Shop?

Modern Retail, Amazon Restricts Additional OpenAI Crawlers

PYMNTS Intelligence, From Prompt to Purchase

OpenAI Help Center, Shopping with ChatGPT Search